Skip To Main Content
Sycamore Community Schools

Benefits/Open Enrollment

2026 Open Enrollment:
November 5 - 18
Employees must log in to the portal beginning November 5 to elect or waive benefits. Failure to do so by November 18 may result in an automatic waiver and/or a loss of coverage if the employee is currently enrolled.

Getting Started

It’s time to enroll for your 2026 benefits! Butler Health Plan (BHP) provides a comprehensive range of medical, prescription, and dental coverage options. All employees must enroll online during the open enrollment window. Failure to enroll could result in a loss of coverage, so don’t miss this important deadline!

We have partnered with American Fidelity as our Section 125 plan provider, offering Flexible Spending Accounts, Health Savings Accounts and supplemental benefit offerings. Keep an eye out for detailed schedules of informational staff meetings in your building. You will also receive instructions soon on how you can sign up for a one-on-one meeting with an American Fidelity representative to help you review and enroll in these benefits for the 2026 plan year.
 
New in 2026: prescription insurance ID cards and dental insurance ID cards will be digital. 

Health Plan Options

Who is Eligible for Benefits?

  • Classified (OAPSE) and Exempt Staff (working 20 hours or more per week)
  • All Certified Staff (SEA)
  • All Administrators

Not sure if you're eligible?

Email: humanresources
@sycamoreschools.org

Monthly Health Rates 

As part of the Butler Health Plan consortium, there have been some cost adjustments this year. To better help you understand the monthly rates and premiums for each plan, please see below: 

MONTHLY RATES: CERTIFIED

monthly rates: CLassified

Medical Plan Options

Click below for a summary of the 2026 medical plan options, including details on the TrueCost plan, and coverage examples. This resource can help you determine which plan is best for you and your family.

 

2026 Medical Plan Options

Health Benefits

Your BHP benefits include a Pharmacy Prescription Plan for medication, free health services at the Butler Advantage Health and Wellness Centers,  and Wellness Programs. Click on the links for more information.

Please note: in 2026, your prescription ID card will be digital. 

Click here to view the entire BHP Open Enrollment Packet. 

Dental Benefits

Choose from Basic, Standard, or Premium dental coverage with varying levels of benefits for basic, major, and orthodontic care. Networks include Delta Dental PPO and Delta Dental Premier.

Please note: in 2026, your dental ID card will be digital. 

Click here to view a summary of the dental plan options for 2026. 

Voluntary Benefits

Employees may also sign up for additional voluntary benefits through American Fidelity including: 

Contact Your American Fidelity Rep

Agent Building Email Phone

Billy Boehme

E.H Greene Intermediate

billy.boehme@americanfidelity.com

513-770-1664

Christina Howard

Blue Ash Elementary

christina.howard@americanfidelity.com

513-770-1671

Christina Howard

District Office

christina.howard@americanfidelity.com

513-770-1671

Christina Howard

Montgomery Elementary

christina.howard@americanfidelity.com

513-770-1671

Christina Howard

Transportation

christina.howard@americanfidelity.com

513-770-1671

Derrick DeWulf

Sycamore High School

derrick.dewulf@americanfidelity.com

513-770-1678

Eric Griswold

Symmes Elementary

eric.griswold@americanfidelity.com

513-770-1684

Phil Fite

Sycamore Junior High

phil.fite@americanfidelity.com

513-478-0214

Phil Fite

Maple Dale Elementary

phil.fite@americanfidelity.com

513-478-0214